Questions to ask a GEO agency before you sign
Ask what they guarantee, how they measure, which tactics Google says to skip, and who owns your accounts when you stop. A vendor who understands AI search guarantees work and reporting, never placement, and measures with a dated log, not a screenshot. A vendor selling certainty promises you will be named.
A disclosure: NovaSapien Labs sells GEO and local AI search services, so these questions apply to us too. Our Front Range AI Visibility Index publishes its limits beside its numbers, and we answer this list about ourselves below.
What are the thirteen questions?
Six groups: what changes, reviews and mentions, measurement, promises, people, and ownership. Each row is explained and sourced below.
| Question | A credible answer | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| 1. What did you find, and what will change? | Written findings, then changes you approve | A package quoted before anyone looked |
| 2. Which tactics does Google say to skip? | Knows them; does not bill for them | llms.txt or "AI schema" as the deliverable |
| 3. A page for every phrasing? | One page per service you offer | Hundreds of near-identical pages |
| 4. How will you get us reviews? | Asking within each platform's rules | Incentives, or asking only happy customers |
| 5. Where will mentions come from? | Sources that exist without the vendor | Site networks or fake customer posts |
| 6. How will we know it worked? | Dated, repeated questions plus Search Console | One screenshot, or an unexplained score |
| 7. Where does your data come from? | Their own sampling, limits stated | Claimed access to ranking data |
| 8. What do you guarantee? | Deliverables, dates and reports | Guaranteed placement |
| 9. What evidence can I check? | Dated, verifiable, relationships disclosed | A percentage with no client or method |
| 10. Who writes and reviews the work? | Named people checking your facts | Unreviewed content at volume |
| 11. What do you know about my trade? | Asks about your customers first | A pitch that fits anyone |
| 12. Who owns the accounts and content? | You do; they get their own login | Vendor-owned accounts, or your password |
| 13. What happens when we stop? | You keep everything | Assets that leave with the vendor |
What will they change?
Only what they can explain and you approve, and no billed work that Google's own guidance says you can ignore.
1. What did you find, and what exactly will you change?
Credible: they study your site, profile, listings and customers' questions, write up findings, and make only changes you approve. Red flag: a package quoted before anyone looked. Google's advice on hiring an SEO warns about companies that will not explain what they intend to do, and says you are responsible for the actions of companies you hire.
2. Which of your tactics does Google say to skip?
Google's guide to its generative AI features says its Search does not use llms.txt files or other "special" markup, and that content needs no chunking and no special schema.org markup, though structured data still helps ordinary SEO. Credible: they know this, do not bill for it, and say other engines publish less. Red flag: llms.txt or "AI schema" sold as what gets you named.
3. Will you publish a page for every phrasing of a question?
The same guide says separate content for every search variation, including the "fan-out" queries its AI runs, made mainly to manipulate rankings or AI answers, violates its scaled content abuse policy. Credible: one page per service you offer, built on facts only you have. Red flag: a proposal counted in hundreds of pages.
Where will reviews and mentions come from?
From real customers, and from sources with no reason to flatter you.
4. How will you get us more reviews?
Google's Maps content policy bans incentives for reviews and selectively asking for positive ones. Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews at all. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews bans fake reviews and paying for reviews of a particular sentiment. Credible: a routine for asking customers, platform by platform. Red flag: a setup that sends only happy customers to Google.
5. Where will mentions and links come from?
Google's AI guide says seeking inauthentic mentions is not as helpful as it might seem, and its spam policies count buying links for ranking as link spam. Credible: local press, associations and lists that exist without the vendor. Red flag: a "network" of sites, or forum posts written to look like customers.
How will they measure it?
With your customers' questions, not their dashboard. Answers vary between people, sessions and days, so one run proves little.
6. How will we know whether it worked?
Credible: a fixed set of your customers' real questions, run in fresh sessions on each engine that matters, dated and repeated, plus Search Console's Generative AI performance report, which counts impressions of links to your site in AI Overviews and AI Mode. Reports include the runs where nothing moved. Red flag: one screenshot, or a score with no published method. Our step-by-step check shows the log.
7. Where does your data come from, and what can't your tool see?
An AI visibility tool samples answers, as you would by hand. Google's guidance on third-party SEO tools says third-party tools, including AEO and GEO tools, "don't have access to our internal ranking data". Credible: what the tool asks, how often, and what it cannot observe. Red flag: claimed access to how an engine ranks, or a "special relationship" with Google, which Google's hiring advice warns about.
What can they honestly promise?
Work, reporting and dates, not placement. OpenAI's ChatGPT search help says: "Placement is not guaranteed."
8. What exactly do you guarantee?
What OpenAI does publish is eligibility: allow its OAI-SearchBot crawler, and let its published IP addresses through your host or CDN. Credible: deliverables with dates, a reporting schedule, and a plain statement that nobody controls the answer. Red flag: guaranteed placement. Google's hiring advice is blunt: if someone guarantees first place, find someone else.
9. What evidence can I check?
Google suggests asking for examples of previous work and checking references with past clients. Credible: a dated before-and-after you can verify live, any relationship with the client disclosed, and what was not measured stated. Red flag: a percentage lift with no client, date or method, or a case study of the vendor's own business that does not say so.
Who will do the work?
Named people you can hold to account, who understand your trade.
10. Who writes and reviews what goes out under our name?
Agencies may subcontract, and AI tools may draft. Neither is disqualifying: Google's AI guide says AI-assisted content must meet the same Search Essentials and spam policies as any other. Credible: named people, every draft checked against your facts, every change shown to you. Red flag: content at volume that nobody on their team can vouch for.
11. What do you know about my trade and my town?
Google says a good SEO asks what makes your business unique, who your competitors are and how customers find you. Credible: questions about your customers before recommendations. Red flag: a pitch that fits any business anywhere. A law firm should ask whether the vendor knows the firm stays responsible for its own communications under Colorado's Rules of Professional Conduct, including what a vendor writes for it, and take ethics questions to ethics counsel. See AI search for Colorado law firms.
Who owns your accounts, and how does it end?
You should own every account and asset, with the vendor as a user you can remove. That is our reasoning, not a legal rule or legal advice.
12. Whose name is on the profile, analytics, domain and content?
A Google Business Profile has one primary owner; owners add and remove users, managers cannot, and each user signs in with their own Google Account. Search Console separates owners from full and restricted users, and Google's hiring advice says to give an SEO doing an audit read access only. Credible: you are primary owner, and the domain, analytics and content belong to your business. Red flag: agency-owned accounts, or a request for your password. See the Google Business Profile guide.
13. What happens when we stop?
Credible: you remove their access yourself, keep every page, listing and file, and get a written record of what changed. On a Business Profile, Google notes, a removed user's past posts and review replies stay. Red flag: pages on the agency's domain, listings in its account, or content that comes down when you leave.
How does NovaSapien Labs answer these?
We sell this work, so the same test applies to us: what we can show, and what we cannot yet.
- Guarantees. We promise no placement.
- Measurement. A dated log of your customers' questions, repeated, and the free scan before and after.
- Method. The Index is published with its limits, and the scan's rubric is on our methodology page.
- Evidence. One case study, Wild Sky Paragliding. Our founder owns that business, and the page says so first. We have no independent client references published yet.
- Prices. On our pricing page: a $750 AI Visibility Audit, credited to setup if you start within 30 days, setup from $1,500, monthly from $750, month to month.
Where should you start?
Know where you stand before the sales call. The free scan reads the page you give it plus robots.txt, sitemap.xml and llms.txt: 26 scored checks across eight dimensions, in seconds. It does not query ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google, and it cannot see your Google Business Profile, so pair it with your own prompt check.
Frequently asked questions
Is GEO different from SEO, and should I pay for both?
Mostly it is the same work. Google says SEO best practices still apply to its generative AI features, which are rooted in its core Search ranking systems. GEO adds checks for other engines' crawlers, more weight on consistent listings, and measuring answers rather than positions. Ask for one scope that lists each task once. The [complete GEO guide](/insights/geo-complete-guide) covers the difference.
What should a GEO engagement cost?
Ours are on the [pricing page](/pricing); we will not quote market rates we have not verified. What belongs in writing before you pay: the deliverables, who does them, the measurement schedule, who owns each account, the notice terms, and what you keep at the end.
How long before results?
Nobody can honestly promise a date; engines refresh their indexes on their own schedules. What a vendor can commit to is a measurement cadence: the same questions rerun on fixed dates, reported whether or not anything moved, with an agreed point to decide whether to continue.
Can I do this without an agency?
Much of it. Google's hiring advice says a small local business can probably do much of its own SEO work. Start with checks, not services: log what the engines say to your customers' questions, and run the free scan.
Sources
- help.openai.com/en/articles/9237897-chatgpt-search
- developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/do-i-need-seo
- developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/third-party-seo
- developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/ai-optimization-guide
- developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies
- support.google.com/contributionpolicy/answer/7400114
- yelp-support.com/article/Don-t-Ask-for-Reviews
- ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-D/part-465
- support.google.com/webmasters/answer/16984139
- support.google.com/business/answer/3403100
- support.google.com/webmasters/answer/7687615
Where we apply this
The trades and cities our research covers, and the service behind it.
More in GEO
Find out what an answer engine can actually read about you.
The free scan reads your site the way an answer engine's crawler does and shows you the gaps to close first. It does not query ChatGPT, Perplexity or Google. That check is the paid AI Visibility Audit.
How we do GEO Run the free scan